Writing Workshop – 30 years and counting!

5281-22-23I began supporting teachers with developing their writing workshops in the 80’s.  Don Graves had written his famous book, Writing: Teachers and Children at Work. Lucy Calkins, Shelley Harwayne, Joanne Hindley and Nancie Atwell visited our county or state conferences and talked about their early work. Before long, their books were on my shelves too. I read it all, soaking it all in, sharing with the teachers at my school, modeling lessons for them, and so on.  As the years went by, I added new writing gurus, like Ralph Fletcher, Carl Anderson, Georgia Heard, and eventually Katie Wood Ray (really enjoyed In Pictures and in Words this summer.) As a Reading Teacher and Coach for elementary school teachers for most of my career, I never tired of reading about writing workshop and how to support students in becoming lifelong writers.  I bet many of you could say that you, too, learned so much from all the names I just mentioned.

Now there are a few new names on the writing front.  And I still find the topic exciting although I’m near the point of fully retiring (which I keep saying will happen “next school year” but my husband doesn’t believe me.) I continue to learn with Rose Cappelli and Lynn Dorfman with all their mentor texts books. Jeff Anderson and Aimee Buckner are also two of my new favorites.  I just finished Aimee’s recent publication called Nonfiction Notebooks (this is her third book on how she uses notebooks.)

41hANbCtgnL._BO2,204,203,200_PIsitb-sticker-arrow-click,TopRight,35,-76_AA278_PIkin4,BottomRight,-64,22_AA300_SH20_OU01_Buckner’s latest book includes her work with upper elementary students as they learn to use their writers’ notebooks to flush out ideas for informational writing topics, narrow their topic to find an angle or focus, try out different leads, experiment with organizational ideas, expand and dig deeper, make decisions about what’s important, and so forth.  She tells you right up front that this book will not include revising and editing of final drafts. It’s Buckner’s belief that the students’ first drafts will be a much better quality if they use some of these prewriting strategies in their notebooks first.  But she cautions us against these scenarios:

  1. The student who begins a first draft way too soon and then there is too much revision work to be done. This can frustrate a student.
  2. The teacher who uses far too many prewriting ideas so that by the time the students begin their drafts, they are tired of their topic.

Some ideas I gathered from Buckner’s new book:

  • On pages 72 and 82 when she is doing a shared demonstration with the kids, she has them glue the excerpt into their notebooks.  So simple, yet why didn’t I think of that?  I usually have the excerpt large enough for all to see and then we might create an anchor chart from the lesson.  When I want to refer back, I’d tell the kids, “Remember when we noticed what so and so did with her description in her NF piece…” It makes more sense to let the kids have the actual excerpt to refer to (with their jottings, things they noticed, and ideas around it.)
  • Using boxes and bullets for organizing ideas (p. 42).  This is something I heard about many years ago, and yet had totally forgotten about.  That’s why we need to keep reading articles, books, and blogs on teaching writing. There’s just too much information out there and sometimes we need reminders.
  • Since the teachers at my school use Readers’ Statements to open their mini-lessons, I appreciated the fact that Aimee began her lessons in a similar way.  Examples of a few: “Writers read informational texts and notice what the authors do”; “Writers write all they know about a topic and then they look for what they don’t know”; “Writers use specific nouns and active verbs to keep their informational writing interesting.”
  • P. 80 – chart of possible leads and the nonfiction books where she found them.
  • Although I don’t have to do report cards, Buckner has included a final chapter on assessment for those teachers who want answers to evaluation questions.

sad-children04Buckner’s book will mostly be helpful to teachers who already have a strong writing workshop in place.  What saddens me most is that even though my county in Virginia (which has 145+ elementary schools) began introducing writing workshop to our teachers in the 80’s, there are still schools where it is just not happening. And that’s a very sad thing for students of all grades.

5 Comments

  1. Hi Pat,
    You have brought back so many memories of my own journey through education. I have those same books on my own bookshelf. They all taught me so much about reading and writing. I have a feeling I am getting ready to add one more book to my shelf. Buckner’s book sounds great and one that I will be able to use a lot. Thanks for all your hard work in our wonderful profession.

  2. Pat,

    I completely agree with the previous comment – this post brought back many memories for me, too. I, too, appreciate all of your work in our profession – I have truly benefited from your work. I love that you can’t retire – I think this is because you love your profession so much and it shows. (It reminds me of our mutual friend, Josie Adler. I never want her to retire. I need her around to support me.) Thanks for all you do.

    Jill

  3. Pat – I completely identify with your post. Thanks so much for sharing, especially the reminder that we need to keep reading even if it is only to remember! Kathleen Schotcher (Stenhouse rep in NC) has suggested many times that we meet. After reading this I am only more sure that she is right. I don’t know how that will happen as I’m in NC, but I wish it was true. Keep writing and telling stories, semi-retired or not! You’re a model for us!

  4. Gwen, Jill, and Karen –
    Thanks for all your positive comments. Now I’ll never be able to retire — I’m a sucker for that positive feedback! I knew there would be a lot of you out there whose journey in writing workshop paralleled mine. I wish all teachers would get the “writing workshop bug.”
    Jill, say HI to Josie!

  5. Pat,
    Thank you for your kind words about my new book. I’m humbled to be included in a post that features such BIG names in education. It’s so true, that we have to keep reading and talking and helping one another remember what we already know and to build upon that knowledge together. It’s really hard for any teacher who thinks s/he has to come up with their own original ideas all of the time. So much of my teaching evolves from what someone taught me.

    Cheers-
    Aimee Buckner

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s